Introduction

Teacher Guide

Printable
Materials

Reading List

Resources

Case Study

Standards

Credits

Bibliography

About the Author

 


 

Senior Participant Evaluation

At the conclusion of the Grandbuddies Project the adult participants were asked to complete a "Grandbuddies Project Evaluation" form. Twenty-two (22) forms were completed and returned. The following are some key points collected from the evaluations:

Question 1: Do you feel that this was a worthwhile program to participate in? Why or why not?
  • 21 participants responded that this was definitely a worthwhile program. 1 participant stated that it "was fun" but questioned whether there was educational value to the project.

  • A sampling of responses:

    • "I feel that this was a very worthwhile program. Activities that bring generations together bring understanding of each other. Children need to know adults have needs. Adults can give children understanding as to what life is and can be. Anything to build a better world is worthwhile."

    • "Yes or no. We all had fun, but is there educational value?"

    • ..."It helped me to be more aware of the opportunities I have with our grandchildren, although we are separated by great distances..."

    • ..." I feel that this was a worthwhile program for the children. Hopefully, they realized that the minds and hearts of older people haven't changed even though our bodies may not be as agile as they once were..."

    • "Yes, it introduced me to the new type of teaching. There are so many advantages today that we did not have."

    • "Absolutely! It builds intergenerational bridges. I find these children to be lucky. In my day we just had to color between the lines."

    • ..."In addition to the obvious, they now know a retirement community isn't just "an old folks" home. My generation grew up with a negative concept..."

    • ..."Some of us don't have the opportunity to interact with young children, and I thank you for that opportunity..."

    • ..."I felt both children and adults gained insight into each other's lives. The delight was simple and rewarding..."
Question 2: Did you have enough opportunity to interact with your buddy?
  • 14 respondents felt that they had enough time to interact with the children.
  • 5 felt that they would have liked more one-on-one time with the child.
  • 3 participants were unsure.
Question 3: What activities did you like the best?
  • 9 participants enjoyed - Touring the school and retirement community with their buddy
  • 9 participants enjoyed - Participating in the interviews
  • 6 participants enjoyed - Singing and dancing together
  • 4 participants enjoyed - Sharing the Memory Book
  • 3 participants enjoyed - Sharing dialogue with children
  • 2 participants enjoyed - Listening to child read
  • 2 participants enjoyed - Sharing photos
  • 2 participants - Couldn't pick a favorite...enjoyed all activities equally
  • 1 participant enjoyed - The refreshments!
Question 4: Do you feel the program was too short, too long, or just right?
  • 14 respondents answered "just right."

  • Other responses included:

    • "Four weeks was just right. If each session could be another 1/2 hour that would remove the rather "rushed" feeling.

    • "The program could be longer. Perhaps 6 weeks..."

    • "I would like for the program to be longer."

    • "4 times was probably enough, but if the sessions could have been longer - perhaps 1 1/2 hours - the time together might have seemed more normal. Grandparents (great-grandparents) don't usually do so many things in one hour!"

    • "Just right...although I wouldn't object to meeting once a month during the school year."

    • "The hour went very fast, but with the school and bus schedule, it was done well. However, perhaps when the visit is at the school the session could be longer."

    • "It would have worked with two more weeks."

    • "Perhaps two more times would have been nice..."
Question 5: Did you feel the program was well organized?
  • All 22 participants responded that they felt the program was very well organized.
Question 6: Do you think you may continue your relationship with your buddy via e-mail in the future?
  • 18 of the Grandbuddies indicated that they are interested in trying to continue the relationship via e-mail in the future.

  • Other responses included:

    • "Since he has no e-mail at home I may not send too much to school. May send notes to his home or school."

    • "I had the feeling that my two little girls weren't as interested in e-mail as I thought they would be. I'd be willing to keep corresponding if they desired to do so, but certainly, in my view, that activity wasn't high on their list of "fun" things to do with a grandbuddy..."

    • "I hope so, but to be truthful, I have my doubts. We do not have enough in common for the children to want to continue e-mailing me."
Question 7: Would you be interested in attending a follow-up visit to Greentown Elementary in May?
  • 21 participants responded "yes" and 1 participant responded "no."
Question 8: What changes might you suggest to improve the program?
  • 9 of the participants did not feel any changes to the program were necessary.

  • 8 of the participants felt that the program would be improved by recruiting more seniors to achieve a 1:1 adult/child ratio. While they enjoyed the program, it was difficult to divide their attention between two children and accomplish the tasks without feeling rushed.

  • 3 respondents felt that the program might be more suitable for a higher grade level.

  • A sampling of other responses:

    • ..."Being a senior computer group, you are dealing with active, interested people and not (perhaps) a cross section of seniors..."

    • "...It might have been interesting to have a ten-minute period where we read to them or with them, which would provide a quiet-time break..."

    • ..."Have the children talk louder...I have hearing aids."

    • "I don't think the children understand what they are doing for the project. The evaluation should be on the children. Ask them how they feel in meeting seniors. Educational-wise, I did not feel that I contributed any."

    • "..More questions about life when seniors were the age of the children. This would provide more interaction between the child and the senior citizens."
Questions 9: If we decide to repeat the program next year, would you be interested in participating again?
  • 19 answered "yes."
  • 1 answered "no."
  • 2 were undecided.